• beehiiv Blog
  • Posts
  • Mastering the Game: How To Create a High-Performing Sports Newsletter

Mastering the Game: How To Create a High-Performing Sports Newsletter

Designing for Victory: Visual and Interactive Elements That Win Readers

Table of Contents

Newsletters are the dark horse that many didn't bet on (that’s rapidly changing), yet they're outpacing more traditional mediums in the race for readers' attention. 

The fact is that a high-performing sports newsletter can draw in an audience that traditional sports media platforms can only dream of. 

The secret? Precision-targeted content that goes beyond scores, schedules, and the conventional confines of mainstream advertising revenue.  

Instead, your audience gets a dose of passion and curiosity right to the heart. 

With the right approach, your newsletter can become an indispensable part of your readers' day—more engaging than the morning paper and more insightful than a quick scroll through headlines.

Here are some key takeaways you’ll learn about in this article:

  • How to blend sports content with compelling storytelling

  • The art of designing a newsletter that's as visually striking as a game-winning goal

  • Insights into segmenting your audience for personalized content delivery

Let's explore how to turn your sports newsletter into the go-to source for fans everywhere.

Mastering the Game: How To Create a High-Performing Sports Newsletter

What To Include in a Sports Newsletter?

Here's how to curate content that turns casual readers into dedicated fans.

Latest Match Reviews and Previews: Get into the nitty-gritty of past games with insightful analyses and offer a sneak peek into upcoming events, highlighting key matchups and players to watch.

Player Spotlights and Interviews: Humanize the athletes by sharing their stories, challenges, and triumphs. Interviews and profiles add a personal touch, building a deeper connection between your readers and their heroes.

Health and Training Tips: Whether it's advice from professional trainers or diet tips for peak performance, sharing health and fitness content positions your newsletter as a valuable resource for aspiring athletes and fitness enthusiasts.

Fan-Centric Features: Interactive sections like reader polls, fantasy league tips, or fan-submitted photos and stories foster a sense of community and engagement, making your subscribers feel like part of the team.

Behind-the-Scenes Content: Offer glimpses into the parts of sports that fans don't usually see, from locker room speeches to training regimens. This exclusive content can make your newsletter a must-read.

Technology and Gear Updates: Cover the latest in sports tech, from new training gadgets to reviews of wearables and equipment. This appeals to readers interested in the intersection of sports and technology.

Creating a Useful and Attractive Sports Newsletter

Mastering the Game: How To Create a High-Performing Sports Newsletter

Creating a useful and attractive sports newsletter requires a blend of good content and eye-catching design. 

Start by defining what sets your newsletter apart. Whether it's exclusive interviews, deep dives into sports analytics, or spotlighting underrepresented sports, find your niche and own it. This will keep people coming back time and time again. 

Once you have that, you can move on to the following:

Don't forget to include a strong call to action (CTA) in each newsletter. Whether you're encouraging readers to subscribe, share your newsletter, or follow your platform on social media, a clear CTA can help grow your audience and increase engagement.

Finally, use analytics to track the performance of your newsletter. Metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and subscriber growth provide valuable insights into what content resonates with your audience. 

Choose an Engaging Contact List for Your Newsletter

Start by targeting subscribers who have shown genuine interest in your sports niche—whether they're avid fans, amateur athletes, or industry professionals. 

Here are two things you need to know when getting started on building your list:

Segmenting Your Audience: Some sports fans may have a keen interest in football, while others live for the basketball season. Use segmentation to categorize your subscribers based on their preferences. This can be done through initial sign-up forms or subscriber behavior on your website.

Mastering the Game: How To Create a High-Performing Sports Newsletter

Utilize interactive sign-up forms on your website and social media platforms. Don't just ask for an email address; engage potential subscribers by asking what sports they're interested in or which teams they follow. 

Regular List Maintenance: Implement a regular schedule to review your list, removing inactive subscribers or those who haven't interacted with your newsletter in a set period.

Mastering the Game: How To Create a High-Performing Sports Newsletter

Building a Design Strategy

When building a design strategy, ask yourself: Is my audience going to be hardcore fans of a particular team, or do they enjoy a broad spectrum of sports? 

This will set the tone early on. 

Keeping your answer in mind, you’ll then want to do the following:

Choose a Color Scheme: This could mean using team colors for a newsletter focused on a specific club or vibrant, dynamic hues for a more general sports theme. The goal is to evoke the excitement of being at a game.

Design Epic Images and Logos: Visuals are often the first thing readers notice, including thumbnails, so choose images that capture the intensity and emotion of the sport.

I touched on this earlier, but I’ll reiterate as it’s important. Your newsletter's layout should be intuitive, making it easy for readers to navigate through the content. 

A cluttered or confusing design can deter readers, so prioritize clarity and ease of use. Break up text with visuals and use headings to delineate different sections or stories clearly.

Mobile Compatibility Matters: Most emails are now opened on mobile devices, so ensure that your newsletter looks great and functions well on all screen sizes. This might mean adjusting image sizes, font sizes, and button placements to enhance readability and interactiveness on smaller screens.

Finally, always be ready to evolve your design based on feedback and performance metrics. 

What works today might not work tomorrow, and the only way to stay ahead is to be adaptable and responsive to your audience's changing preferences.

Why Trust Me? Russell, the founder of InboxConnect marketing agency, has over five years of deep expertise in email marketing. Under his leadership, the agency has become known for innovative strategies with notable successes, including campaigns for renowned clients like Payoneer.

Using User-Friendly Templates

Mastering the Game: How To Create a High-Performing Sports Newsletter

Finding a sports newsletter template that's both visually appealing and easy to use can significantly streamline the creation process. 

Begin by choosing templates that offer straightforward customization. This means easy drag-and-drop features, editable color schemes, and the ability to switch out images or adjust layouts without a hitch. 

The goal is a high-impact design with low-effort input, allowing you to focus more on content than on troubleshooting design issues.

Remember that your audience checks their email across various devices, so your newsletter template must be responsive. This ensures that whether your readers are on a desktop during halftime or checking their phones on the sidelines, your newsletter delivers a seamless experience. 

Fun fact: If you’re using beehiiv, you won’t have to worry too much about optimizing for mobile, as the platform takes care of this for you. 

Before settling on a template, review examples from leading sports newsletters for inspiration. Look at what they do – their use of whitespace, typography, or how they incorporate multimedia elements like videos and GIFs. 

Let me break it down for you further:

  • Use straightforward customizable templates that allow for easy modifications of layout, color schemes, and fonts without the need for complex software or coding skills.

  • Design or look for templates that can be adapted to a wide range of content types and styles, accommodating everything from detailed articles and reports to quick updates and multimedia content.

  • Make sure that your chosen template is compatible with major email marketing platforms and providers, ensuring smooth integration and reliable performance across different email clients and devices.

It’s worth noting that while beehiiv might not offer built-in templates, they support the creativity and flexibility needed to adapt any inspiring template you find into something uniquely yours.

Best Sports Newsletter Ideas

Inspiring Stories 

These inspiring newsletters will deepen the connection between your newsletter and its audience. 

An excellent example is The Players' Tribune, which offers firsthand accounts from athletes about their journeys, challenges, and triumphs.

Mastering the Game: How To Create a High-Performing Sports Newsletter

Here are five other ideas for inspiring stories you could write:

  • Underdogs to Champions: Stories of teams or athletes who defied the odds

  • Sports Psychology Insights: Exploring mental resilience in competitive sports

  • Barrier Breakers: Highlighting achievements in diversity and inclusion within sports realms

  • Youth in Sports: Spotlighting rising young talents and their journeys

  • Comeback Chronicles: Focusing on athletes returning from injury or personal challenges

Upcoming Events

Offer exclusive content such as pre-event analysis, expert predictions, and behind-the-scenes looks at event preparations. This positions your newsletter as an essential resource for sports fans. 

Here are five examples of upcoming event newsletters you could start:

  • Local Leagues Spotlight: A focus on regional sporting events and leagues

  • Marquee Matchups: Previews of high-stakes games across different sports

  • International Sports Calendar: Covering global sporting events and how to watch them

  • Fantasy Sports Picks: Offering insights and predictions for fantasy sports enthusiasts

  • Off-Season Highlights: Keeping fans engaged with updates and news in the off-season

Technology in Sports

Shed light on the latest technological advancements that are revolutionizing sports, from performance-enhancing wearables to cutting-edge training methodologies. 

Incorporate reviews of new gadgets and delve into how analytics and data are influencing sports strategies.

Here are three solid examples I think you could run with:

  • eSports Evolution: Covering the rise and impact of eSports alongside traditional sports

  • Sports Analytics Breakdown: How data is changing game strategies and fan experiences

  • Virtual Reality Training: Innovations in VR and AR for training and fan engagement

Sports Brands

Explore the impact of sports brands on the industry, covering everything from the latest gear innovations to major sponsorship deals. 

Monthly or weekly spotlights on brands or product reviews can offer readers valuable insights while adding an interactive element through exclusive discounts or offers.

Another example might be a football newsletter that features exclusive previews of the season's biggest matches and talks about the latest gear from leading football brands.

Healthy Tips for Athletes

Provide practical health and fitness advice from experts, covering nutrition, mental health, and injury prevention. This segment can significantly benefit your readers, offering them actionable tips to enhance their athletic performance and overall well-being. For instance, Runner's World offers a blend of expert advice and tips for athletes of all levels, serving as a great model for how to structure this type of content.

Sports Newsletter Examples To Inspire You

Here are two real-world examples of successful sports newsletters that I think you’ll love.

Playmaker Newsletter

Mastering the Game: How To Create a High-Performing Sports Newsletter

The Playmaker Newsletter stands out as a prime example of a sports newsletter done right. It's a treasure trove for any sports enthusiast looking for more than just scores and stats. 

Here’s what makes it a go-to resource:

  • Up-to-Date Sports Analysis

  • Unique Insight

  • Engaging Content

For anyone aiming to create a compelling sports newsletter, Playmaker serves as a stellar example of balancing expertise with an engaging narrative, ensuring that each edition is eagerly anticipated by its subscriber base.

Sports 3.0

Mastering the Game: How To Create a High-Performing Sports Newsletter

The Sports 3.0 Newsletter is a forward-thinking resource that explores the intersection of sports, technology, and digital innovation. It offers a unique perspective on how emerging technologies are reshaping the sports industry, from fan engagement to athlete performance. 

Here's why it stands out:

  • Innovative Sports Analysis

  • Cutting-Edge Trends

  • Bridges Tech With Sports

For creators with aspirations, writing a newsletter with a tech-savvy edge, Sports 3.0 provides an excellent blueprint. 

Sports Newsletter Ideas: Frequently Asked Questions

How To Make a Sports Newsletter

Kickstart your sports newsletter by zeroing in on your passion within the sports world. Leverage tools like beehiiv to streamline the setup, focusing on areas that spark interest among your audience— a specific sport, team, or the broader culture around sports. 

Curate and create content that resonates, blending analyses, updates, and narratives to keep your audience hooked. Enhance reader engagement with interactive elements and maintain a sleek, easy-to-navigate design.

How To Write a Sports Newsletter

Captivate your audience right off the bat with headlines that pack a punch and content that keeps readers on the edge of their seats.

Employ storytelling to transform dry stats and game summaries into compelling narratives. Enrich your newsletter with insights from experts and behind-the-scenes peeks to cement your status as a must-read for sports enthusiasts.

Incorporating images and quotes? Mind the legal playing field by ensuring that all copyrighted materials are used with permission or sourced from royalty-free collections. 

Attribute quotes accurately to uphold integrity and avoid legal pitfalls. Staying informed about copyright and fair use rights is key to safeguarding your newsletter against infringement claims.

What Are Some Tips for Writing About Sensitive Topics in Sports, Like Injuries or Controversies?

When diving into the delicate zones of sports—be it injuries or controversies—precision, empathy, and responsible reporting are your best allies.

Confirm facts through trustworthy channels, present issues with sensitivity, and offer balanced viewpoints to respect the subjects and your readers alike. This careful approach not only respects those involved but also builds your newsletter’s credibility and trustworthiness.

The Winning Game Plan

Just like life in sports, getting your newsletter to stand out requires more than just passion for the game.

You’ll need a strategic blend of engaging content, sharp design, and a deep understanding of your audience's interests. From the grassroots tales of perseverance to the cutting-edge developments in sports technology, every piece of your newsletter should aim to inform, engage, and inspire.

Remember, the most successful sports newsletters do more than report scores; they capture the spirit of sportsmanship, the thrill of competition, and the community of fans behind every team and athlete. 

By following these strategies, you're well on your way to joining the ranks of the best sports newsletters out there.

What are you waiting for? Are you ready to start your own sports newsletter and engage with a community of passionate fans? 

Sign up for beehiiv today and turn your vision into reality. Now's the time to take the field and show the world what your newsletter is made of.

Join the conversation

or to participate.