• beehiiv Blog
  • Posts
  • The Battle of Email Marketing Giants: ConvertKit Vs. Mailchimp Vs beehiiv

The Battle of Email Marketing Giants: ConvertKit Vs. Mailchimp Vs beehiiv

Which Email Marketing Platform Is Right for You? ConvertKit Vs Mailchimp Vs beehiiv

The Email Marketing Opponents 

Email marketing has proven to be the most effective marketing type in today's landscape.

Every marketer knows this, and they want their share in the fight for new customers. 

As email marketing becomes more relevant, the  "big three" companies stand up as the best partners for every email marketer to win the war for new customers. 

These companies are beehiiv, Mailchimp, and ConvertKit.

In this article, we will deep dive into each platform, its benefits, its tools for email marketing, and its cons to help you determine which one is the best fit for your needs.

Table of Contents

Mailchimp Vs ConvertKit Vs beehiiv: Which Is Best for Your Email Marketing Needs?

Email marketing is a cornerstone of any successful digital marketing strategy. It allows you to connect with your audience, build brand loyalty, know your readers' behaviors and preferences, and drive conversions and sales.


The Battle of Email Marketing Giants: ConvertKit Vs. Mailchimp Vs beehiiv

Mailchimp is a popular email marketing platform that offers many features to help businesses and organizations create, manage, and optimize their email marketing campaigns. Here are some key features of Mailchimp:

Email Campaigns: Mailchimp provides an easy-to-use email campaign builder with a drag-and-drop interface. Users can create and customize email templates, and add images, text, and buttons to design engaging email content.

Marketing Automation: Mailchimp offers robust marketing automation tools, allowing users to set up automated email sequences triggered by user actions or behaviors. This includes welcome emails, abandoned cart emails, follow-up sequences, and more.

Segmentation: Users can segment their email lists based on various criteria, such as demographics, purchase history, engagement level, and more. Segmentation helps deliver highly targeted and personalized content to different audience segments.

A/B Testing: A/B testing allows users to experiment with different email elements (subject lines, content, send times) to determine what performs best. Mailchimp provides A/B testing tools to optimize email campaigns.

Reporting and Analytics: Mailchimp offers detailed reports on campaign performance, including open rates, click-through rates, conversion rates, and revenue generated. Users can track the success of their email campaigns and make data-driven decisions.

Integration: Mailchimp integrates with a wide range of third-party applications and services, including e-commerce platforms, CRM software, social media platforms, and more. This ensures seamless connectivity with other tools used in your marketing stack.

Signup Forms and Landing Pages: Users can create custom signup forms and landing pages to capture leads and grow their email lists. Mailchimp provides templates and customization options to match branding and design preferences.

Personalization: Personalization features enable users to insert dynamic content, such as subscribers' names or product recommendations, into their emails for a more personalized experience.

RSS-to-Email: Automatically send email updates to subscribers whenever new content is added to your website or blog using the RSS-to-email feature.

Mobile Accessibility: Mailchimp offers a mobile app, making it convenient to manage email campaigns, view reports, and monitor subscriber engagement from your mobile device.

E-commerce Integration: Mailchimp has specific features for e-commerce businesses, including product retargeting emails, purchase tracking, and product recommendations.

Social Media Ads: In addition to email marketing, Mailchimp allows users to create and manage social media advertising campaigns, integrating email and social media marketing efforts.

Transactional Emails: Send automated transactional emails, such as order confirmations and shipping notifications, through Mailchimp's transactional email service, Mandrill.

Content Studio: Store and manage all your email campaign assets, including images and files, in Mailchimp's Content Studio for easy access and reuse.

Mailchimp's user-friendly interface and comprehensive features make it a popular choice for businesses of all sizes looking to streamline their email marketing efforts and engage with their audiences effectively. 

The platform offers both free and paid plans, making it accessible to a wide range of users.


The Battle of Email Marketing Giants: ConvertKit Vs. Mailchimp Vs beehiiv

ConvertKit is an email marketing platform designed primarily for creators, bloggers, online course creators, and small businesses. 

Ryan Holiday uses ConvertKit to reach his +1M readers each day. Ryan mentioned in a Q&A article that "he uses ConvertKit, which is excellent if you send lots of emails and plan to sell anything directly through your list. They have good customer service and good technology."

ConvertKit offers a range of features tailored to help content creators effectively engage with their audiences and grow their email lists. Here are some key features of ConvertKit:

Subscriber Segmentation: ConvertKit allows you to segment your email list based on subscriber behaviors, interests, and characteristics, a key ingredient in email marketing success.

This segmentation feature helps you send highly targeted and relevant content to specific subscriber groups.

Automation Rules: ConvertKit offers powerful automation capabilities through its "Visual Automation" feature. 

You can create complex email sequences, workflows, and automation rules to send the right messages at the right times based on subscriber actions or triggers.

Customizable Forms and Landing Pages: Landing pages are crucial to get subscribers. 

With ConvertKit, you can create custom signup forms and landing pages to capture leads and grow your email list. ConvertKit provides templates and customization options to match your branding and design preferences.

Email Sequences: Design and automate email sequences, such as welcome series, onboarding emails, or sales funnels, to nurture and convert subscribers over time.

Personalization: Personalize your emails with merge tags to include subscribers' names and other dynamic content, creating a more personalized experience.

Tagging System: Use tags to label subscribers based on their actions or interests. Tags make it easy to organize and segment your audience for targeted campaigns.

Analytics and Reporting: Get insights into your email campaign performance with ConvertKit's reporting tools. Track open rates, click-through rates, conversion rates, and more to assess the effectiveness of your email marketing efforts.

Integrations: Connect ConvertKit with other tools and platforms you use in your marketing stack, including e-commerce platforms, CRM systems, and content management systems, to streamline your workflow.

Deliverability Optimization: ConvertKit places a strong emphasis on email deliverability, ensuring that your emails reach subscribers' inboxes and not their spam folders.

API Access: For advanced users, ConvertKit offers API access, allowing for deeper integration and customization.

Support and Education: ConvertKit provides educational resources, including webinars, workshops, and guides, to help users maximize the platform's capabilities.

Migration Assistance: ConvertKit offers migration assistance for users transitioning from other email marketing platforms to ensure a smooth transition.

ConvertKit's focus on segmentation, automation, and customization makes it an attractive choice for creators and bloggers looking to build strong relationships with their audiences and effectively market their content and products. 

The platform's simplicity and user-friendly interface make it accessible to users at various skill levels.


The Battle of Email Marketing Giants: ConvertKit Vs. Mailchimp Vs beehiiv

User-Friendly Interface: beehiiv stands out with its exceptionally user-friendly interface, ensuring that even those new to email marketing can effortlessly craft professional newsletters. 

The intuitive design allows you to navigate the platform seamlessly, focusing on creating engaging content for your subscribers.

Customizable Templates: beehiiv offers diverse templates designed to cater to various industries and niches. 

This enables you to infuse your newsletters with your brand's unique aesthetics and messaging, ensuring a visually appealing and brand-consistent look.

Drag-and-Drop Editor: beehiiv simplifies the newsletter design process with its drag-and-drop editor, eliminating the need for coding expertise.

Easily add text, images, buttons, and social media links to your newsletters by intuitively dragging and dropping elements onto the canvas. 

This feature saves time and guarantees a polished and professional appearance.

Importing and Exporting Subscribers: beehiiv streamlines subscriber management by offering effortless import and export capabilities through CSV files or seamless integration with your existing Customer Relationship Management (CRM) software. 

This ensures that your subscriber data remains up-to-date and accurate.

Segmentation and Targeting: Unlock the power of personalization by segmenting your subscribers based on their interests and preferences.

beehiiv provides robust segmentation features that empower you to create precisely targeted campaigns that resonate with specific audience segments, leading to higher engagement and conversion rates.

Subscriber Analytics: Gaining insights into your subscribers' behavior and preferences is pivotal for optimizing your newsletter strategy. 

beehiiv equips you with comprehensive subscriber analytics, offering valuable data on open rates, click-through rates, and subscriber engagement. 

Armed with this knowledge, you can fine-tune your content and delivery strategies to maximize the impact of your newsletters.

Email Deliverability: beehiiv prioritizes email deliverability to ensure that your newsletters consistently land in your subscribers' inboxes rather than their spam folders. 

With dependable deliverability rates, you can confidently expect your messages to reach their intended recipients, enhancing your lead generation and conversion prospects.

Automation and Scheduling: Save time and effort by automating your newsletter campaigns. beehiiv's automation and scheduling features empower you to create drip campaigns, welcome sequences, and automated follow-ups. 

Additionally, you can schedule newsletters to be sent at optimal times, significantly boosting subscriber engagement.

Integration with Third-Party Platforms: beehiiv seamlessly integrates with popular third-party platforms, including CRM systems, e-commerce platforms, Ad platforms, and content management systems. 

This integration streamlines your workflows and harnesses the full potential of your existing tools, amplifying the effectiveness of your newsletter strategy.

Analytics and Performance Tracking

Open and Click Rates: beehiiv delivers comprehensive analytics on open rates and click-through rates, offering invaluable insights into the performance of your newsletter campaigns. 

Armed with this data, you can identify areas for improvement, fine-tune your content, and optimize your call-to-action buttons to drive higher engagement.

Subscriber Engagement Metrics: In addition to open and click rates, beehiiv tracks subscriber engagement metrics such as the time spent reading newsletters and the frequency of interactions. 

These metrics provide a deeper understanding of your audience's behavior and preferences, enabling you to tailor your content to their interests and boost overall engagement.

AI: beehiiv is the only email platform that has enhanced AI to assist email marketers in creating unique images or crafting compelling writing using AI. 

With short prompts, you can create unique masterpieces.

ConvertKit vs. Mailchimp vs. beehiiv: Getting Started

When choosing an email marketing platform, consider the following factors:

The Battle of Email Marketing Giants: ConvertKit Vs. Mailchimp Vs beehiiv

1. Your Audience 

With all three platforms, you can create a newsletter with personality. They allow you to upload images, personalize fonts, colors, etc.

beehiiv is preferred when it comes to keeping your brand in perfect shape so all your emails and website are consistent and resonate with your audience.

Another essential aspect that makes beehiiv different from its competitors is the precise data it offers about your readers. 

When you want to go deeper into your audience's behaviors and find what is resonating, beehiiv’s 3D analytics tool provides the answers. 

2. Features 

These three companies are the "big three" for a reason. They all provide the essential features to enable your newsletter to win at email marketing. 

They all offer good templates to give personality to your email newsletter and solid segmentation and automation tools. 

Each of these tools provides similar features making them all good options in their own right. However, ConvertKit and beehiiv provide A/B testing tools to help you get more eyeballs on your content and see which one works better for your audience.

Where beehiiv leaves the competition behind is with its AI integration tools. With AI tools, one man can do the work of a team. 

Which features are most important to you? Do you need advanced automation, subscriber segmentation, or AI-powered insights?

3. Budget 

All three platforms offer free plans to start your newsletter.
The big difference here is the size of the email list.

Mailchimp and ConvertKit offer their free plan for an email list of only 1000 subscribers, while with beehiiv you can build an email list for up to 2,500 subscribers and then opt for paid plans.

beehiiv is the best option to keep your budget in check without surprises. 

4. Integration Needs 

Both beehiiv and ConvertKit offer easy integration with other third-party apps to boost your arsenal. 

Mailchimp has some cons here since integrating with other platforms can be challenging and sometimes impossible. 

5. Ease of Use 

All three platforms are easy to use and set up. You can create your newsletter in a few minutes.

beehiiv and ConvertKit stand up here with their easy creation of a landing page to help you grab more subscribers. However, beehiiv has a drag-and-drop option that offers more personalization and allows you to keep your brand intact around every corner. 


The Battle of Email Marketing Giants: ConvertKit Vs. Mailchimp Vs beehiiv

In conclusion, Mailchimp, ConvertKit, and beehiiv all have their strengths and are suitable for different types of users. 

Mailchimp is beginner-friendly and offers a wide range of features, while ConvertKit is ideal for creators who need advanced segmentation and automation. beehiiv stands out with its AI-driven insights and visual campaign builder.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific requirements and goals. 

Regardless of your choice, these tools can help you take your email marketing efforts to the next level and drive better results for your business.

With its top-tier tools, advanced segmentation, competitive pricing, and integration capabilities, beehiiv is the clear winner.

Sign up now for beehiiv and unleash the power of the best platform for email marketing.

Join the conversation

or to participate.