• beehiiv Blog
  • Posts
  • The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Unlocking the Secrets of Engaging and Profitable Financial Newsletters

Table of Contents

Now, more than ever, financial services newsletters are the unsung heroes of our ever-evolving digital financial landscape. 

Why, you ask?

Because the world of finance never stands still, it's a high-speed race with new opportunities sprouting up daily.

These newsletters are not just your run-of-the-mill updates but your secret weapon for staying ahead in this dynamic financial arena. 

Take Milk Road, for instance, a champion in the game, delivering daily doses of financial insight in a way that makes you actually enjoy reading it.

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

But here's the real scoop: these newsletters are more than just entertaining reads; they hold the power to transform your financial journey. 

With market trends and investment advice at your fingertips, they become your trusty sidekick in shaping your financial strategy, boosting your financial know-how, and inching you closer to your financial dreams.

These newsletters aren't just about numbers and stats and building trust. 

Because once you've got an engaged, trusting audience, you've got a nearly unstoppable business.

So if you're contemplating launching your own financial services newsletter, consider this guide to be your guiding light. 

Keep reading as I unravel the secrets of kickstarting your very own financial services newsletter and navigating the exciting terrain ahead.

Let’s get into it.

Key Components of a Financial Services Newsletter

In this fast-paced arena, where everyone is vying for attention, your financial service newsletter needs to be more than just informative. 

It needs to be unforgettable.

It should house curated content, meticulously organized and efficiently delivered, setting you apart from the crowd. 

Here are some key components to note when compiling your newsletter. 

Compelling Subject Lines 

A newsletter's subject line is your readers' first impression, and it can often determine whether the email gets opened.

Just think how many times you’ve read a subject line and thought… Nope! Not opening that.

To create a compelling subject line, keep it concise, make it action-oriented, and, if it fits your brand's voice, don't be afraid to make it a bit catchy or evocative. 

Personalizing subject lines with the reader's name or other relevant data can also increase your open rates. 

Here are two examples of high-performing subject lines: 

  • 5 market updates you just missed

  • What the heck is Bitcoin halving? 🤷‍♂️

Introduction and Greeting 

Just like your subject line, the first lines of your newsletter help set the tone. You got to get it right! 

A personalized greeting can make the reader feel valued, and a bit of enthusiasm can go a long way. 

You’d be surprised how much a polite "Good morning" or a more enticing "We've got exciting news to share" can make a world of difference.

Also, consider utilizing your greeting to thank the reader for their time or recall a past interaction, adding a relational feel to your communication.

How to personalize posts with custom fields using beehiiv:

Setting the Tone for Content 

As you move beyond the greeting and into the main body of the newsletter, consistency is key for setting the right tone. 

Maintain your brand's voice across all channels of communication and aim for a balance of formality and friendliness that fits within the financial industry's expectations. 

Then again, you can carve out your own channel and go completely against the grain if you have high ambitions. 

However, I’d strictly recommend only doing this if you have a large following already or are very experienced in email copywriting. 

Finally, conciseness is your superpower here. Great content can lose its punch if buried in long paragraphs. 

Be helpful, informative, and direct.

Feature Articles 

Feature articles are a valuable tool for those looking to start their own financial services newsletter. 

They involve in-depth exploration of specific topics, combining storytelling with concrete facts to engage readers. This approach is particularly effective for discussing hot topics or providing a distinctive viewpoint. 

Not only can feature articles enhance your credibility in the field, but they might also lead to future opportunities for paid contributions, making them a strategic choice for your newsletter journey. 

Market Updates 

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Use visual tools like graphs and charts to share market updates for your financial services newsletter. 

Keep it brief—provide essential information without lengthy reports. 

This way, your newsletter becomes a valuable resource for your readers.

Expert Insights 

Including expert opinions offers valuable insights, and it helps signify you're at the forefront of financial newsletters. 

Be selective about the guest experts you feature to match the standards and expectations of your readers. 

Client Success Stories 

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Whether it's a testimonial or a full-fledged case study, sharing stories of satisfied clients can boost your credibility and demonstrate the practicability of your personal finance newsletter. 

Remember to seek necessary permissions before you share those stories. 

Educational Content 

Ever heard of edutainment? 

Structuring complex financial concepts in an easy, engaging, and educational manner makes learning enjoyable and more likely to be retained by your readers. 

It's a great way to empower your subscribers and foster a stronger connection. 

Upcoming Events or Webinars 

If you've got an upcoming webinar or financial event, let your readers know! 

Convey the benefits of attending the event and perhaps offer a 'newsletter subscriber' discount to encourage sign-ups. 

Curated Content 

Sharing hand-picked content from other reputable resources adds variety and reflects your commitment to value addition. 

Just make sure to always give credit where it's due. 

Call to Action (CTA) 

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

A well-placed CTA is a crucial component of your financial services newsletter. It prompts readers to take a specific action, such as signing up for a webinar, subscribing to a premium service, or exploring your investment recommendations further. 

The CTA should be clear, persuasive, and aligned with your newsletter's objectives, encouraging your audience to engage and benefit from your financial expertise.

Contact Information 

Always provide clear contact details. 

It might seem obvious, but sometimes newsletters forget to include essential info like the customer service email or hotline. 

Unsubscribe Option 

While it's disheartening to see a reader go, providing an easy-to-find unsubscribe option improves the user experience and respects their inbox. 

Plus, it complies with international email marketing laws, keeping your operations legal and ethical. 

Best Practices for Creating a Financial Services Newsletter

Just like anything else in life, my friend, consistency is the name of the game here. Your subscribers eagerly await your newsletter's arrival like it's a ritual. 

Just imagine how weird it would feel if FRIENDS didn’t air for one of their weekly shows.

If you start playing hide and seek with your newsletter schedule, that's a surefire way to lose their interest or have your newsletter buried beneath a mountain of unread emails.

The magic lies in a regular and predictable schedule.

This keeps them informed and engaged, forging a sense of trust and reliability that's pure gold in the world of newsletters.

Speaking of friends, you don't want to be that friend who texts incessantly, nor do you want to be the one who disappears for months on end. 

Strike the right balance, and your subscribers will thank you for it. 

Segmenting and Personalization

Now, let’s talk about Segmenting.

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Segmentation is all about understanding your audience deeply. A one-size-fits-all approach may not cater to diverse financial interests. 

By grouping your readers based on shared characteristics or preferences, you can tailor content to pique their interest. 

Leveraging behavioral data can be a game-changer, allowing you to dynamically adjust content based on reader interactions for an ultra-personalized experience. 

Here are some examples of segments you could include in your financial newsletter:

Investment Experience Levels:

  • Novice Investors

  • Intermediate Investors

  • Experienced Investors

Financial Goals:

  • Retirement Planning

  • Wealth Accumulation

  • Debt Management


  • Age Groups (e.g., Millennials, Gen X, Baby Boomers)

  • Income Levels (e.g., High-Income Earners, Middle-Income Earners)

Investment Preferences:

  • Stocks and Equities

  • Real Estate

  • Bonds and Fixed Income

  • Cryptocurrency

Similarly, personalizing the newsletter enhances your bond with your reader. 

From using the subscriber's name to tailoring content based on preferences and adding personal touches, it will make all the difference. 

Target Audience

And this brings me to your target audience

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Before you start piecing together your finance newsletter, let's get one thing straight: who exactly are you trying to reach? 

Identifying your target audience is like setting the GPS for your newsletter journey.

Below are some ideas to help you identify your target audience:

  • Small Businesses in Accounting

  • Estate Planning Entrepreneurs

  • Senior Partners in Investment Banking 

  • Private Wealth Management

  • Tech Startup Founders

  • Retail Investors

I think you get the point! 

Knowing who's going to read your stuff is crucial. 

It’ll shape your newsletter, ensuring that you hit the nail on the head with content that resonates and sparks action. Think of it as your North Star, guiding every topic and every piece of info you decide to include. 

Get this right, and you're golden! 

Content Creation

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

In terms of content, remember that quality surpasses quantity. 

Your readers' time is precious, so prioritize well-researched and accurate information that enhances their financial knowledge. 

Invest effort in readability, use appealing visuals, and back your insights with solid data. 

This way, you ensure that every moment your audience spends with your newsletter is genuinely rewarding.

Mobile Optimization

Creating responsive newsletters that display correctly on all devices improves user experience and drastically reduces the likelihood of subscribers deleting your email or marking it as spam. 

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Call To Action & A/B Testing

Last but not least, creating effective CTAs and conducting A/B testing are integral to newsletter success. 

The right call to action can be a powerful tool to spur readers into action, be it signing up for a webinar, downloading an investment guide, or collaborating with a financial adviser. 

A/B testing helps refine these CTAs for maximum impact alongside subject lines, content, and design aspects. 

By comparing two versions, A/B tests provide evidence-based conclusions on what truly works for your audience. 

Executing these strategies ensures a well-crafted newsletter and a communication channel that caters to your readers' interests and helps them better inform their financial decisions.

Why Trust Me?

I bring expertise, results-driven strategies, and a powerful arsenal of email marketing knowledge to supercharge your business. 

With a track record of driving substantial revenue through compelling copy, I'm here to help make an impact on your email marketing efforts.

Advanced Techniques and Strategies

Imagine your newsletter coming to life through interactive elements like quizzes and surveys. 

This can turn your newsletter from a passive reading experience into an engaging conversation. 

Creating Two-Way Communication

Think of exciting ways to create a dynamic bridge or two-way channel where your subscribers can actively engage. 

When you introduce these interactive experiences like polls, you're no longer just sharing information; you're igniting a more profound connection between your readers and your financial insights. 

This sparks a powerful loyalty bond that keeps them returning for more.

Behavioral Triggers for Personalization

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Setting up behavioral triggers is another vital strategy to boost personalization and engagement. 

This involves tracking reader actions or preferences and responding with targeted automated content. 

For instance, if a subscriber shows interest in investment tips, your system could automatically send newsletters addressing that topic.

The Power of Automation

Speaking of automation, its role extends beyond sending personalized content. Automation tools can help analyze reader behavior, segment your audience, and send newsletters at optimal times. 

Multichannel Integration for Amplified Reach

Now, let's move on to multichannel integration. Seamlessly connecting your newsletters with social media and other communication channels amplifies your reach and creates a cohesive experience for your subscribers. 

Imagine this: you can share enticing snippets or pivotal insights from your newsletters on your social media platforms. 

It's like leaving a trail of breadcrumbs that lead interested readers straight to your newsletter sign-up.

But the real magic happens when you fully integrate your financial newsletter strategy with these channels. 

This opens up a treasure trove of possibilities, from boosting your social proof by showcasing your expertise to driving interactions that transcend any single platform. 

It's all about creating a web of engagement that keeps your audience hooked and hungry for more financial wisdom.

Ensuring Data Privacy Compliance

Last but certainly not least is ensuring compliance with data privacy regulations. 

Your subscribers entrust you with their information; keeping it secure is about meeting legal requirements like GDPR and maintaining their trust and confidence

Keep your newsletter strategies transparent, allow subscribers to easily opt-out, and use security precautions to protect their information. 

Remember, a secure newsletter service is part and parcel of being a trusted financial advisor.

Measuring Success and Analytics

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Let's talk about metrics. I'm here to spark a love affair with tracking these numbers because they reveal a compelling story far richer than mere percentages and flashy graphs.

Among the key characters in this story are the open rate, the click-through rate, and the occasionally daunting unsubscribe rate. 

Unsubscribes, in particular, serve as a clear signal—did your content inadvertently nudge readers towards the exit? 

On the other hand, open and click-through rates are the chapters that unveil the depth of engagement, painting a vivid picture of your audience's journey through your newsletter.

Subscriber Growth and Retention

Keeping tabs on subscriber growth and retention rates is essential. A thriving newsletter should see a steady uptick in subscribers over time. 

Retention rates, on the other hand, reveal how well you're keeping your audience captivated.

Subscriber Growth Metrics

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Growth Rate: Aim for a consistent growth rate, ideally month-over-month. This rate varies by size and niche, but a healthy newsletter should see at least a 5-10% growth monthly.

Acquisition Channels: Track which channels (social media, referrals, paid ads) bring in the most subscribers to optimize your marketing efforts.

Conversion Rate: Monitor the conversion rate from visitors to subscribers on your website. A good conversion rate is typically around 2-5%.

Retention Rates:

Churn Rate: The industry standard for a healthy newsletter is a monthly churn rate of less than 5%. In finance, where information is critical, lower churn rates are preferable.

Engagement Metrics: Track open rates and click-through rates. A good open rate is around 20-30%, and a 2-5% click-through rate is considered healthy. 

Look to see if there are specific topics that consistently spark higher engagement. 

If so, consider talking about that topic often in your newsletters. 

Your analytics hold the answers. 

However, don't just skim the surface; delve deeper. 

For instance, a dip in open rates may seem concerning; but if click-through rates hold steady, it means readers are still invested.

Case Studies and Real-Life Examples

The Pomp Letter

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Anthony Pompliano's The Pomp Letter is a killer example of how diverse experiences can supercharge a digital media empire. 

Think about it – from military service to rocking roles at Facebook and Snapchat and then diving into the startup investment scene.

Pomp smartly tapped into the growing buzz around blockchain and bitcoin, kicking off with a niche newsletter and then amplifying his reach with podcasting. This move? It's pure gold for audience building.

His hustle doesn't stop there. With a tight schedule of almost daily content, he has nailed the art of keeping his audience hooked. 

And the revenue game? It's as dynamic as his background, with a mix of ad subscriptions, a paid newsletter, and earnings from his roles at Morgan Creek Digital and his personal fund. 

This guy's business savvy has turned The Pomp Letter into a standout success story in the digital space.

And get this – he has recently launched his own rolling fund, raking in a cool $20 million in just a few weeks. 

Talk about crushing it!

Milk Road

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

I’m well aware that Milk Road is very likely your inspiration for wanting to start a financial services newsletter.

Our buddies at Milk Road birthed the idea from a cold DM on Twitter, just before 2021's New Year's Eve, that suggested launching a crypto newsletter. 

Fast forward to today, and I think we can all agree everyone loves Milk Road

So what made them such a success?

The design was key. Absolutely! 

But Milk Road did something no one else was doing in the space.

They began building a brand. In a sea of bland newsletters, this one screams, “Read me!”

They also leveraged our awesome referral program with great success.

Simplicity is the name of the game, folks. 

Milk Road wasn't just playing; they were winning. 

With over 175,000 organic search impressions in three months, they knew their SEO game

They also dabbled in paid acquisition, dropping some serious coin on Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok ads. Spoiler alert: meme ads and social proof ads were their golden tickets.

Engagement, though? 

Milk Road didn't just talk; they listened. 

Through beehiiv's polls, they got real-time feedback, boosting that crucial CTR and engagement. 

They asked, listened, and adapted – a feedback loop on steroids.

In less than 10 months, from a Twitter DM to acquisition, Milk Road wasn't just a newsletter; it was a marketing masterclass. 

They leveraged beehiiv's full suite - from design to analytics - and made every click count. 

By creating killer content, testing all acquisition channels, and focusing on what mattered most, they became a rapid success story, a blueprint for anyone wanting to make it big in the newsletter world.

You can read more about Milk Road’s story here

Today, newsletters must keep pace with cutting-edge trends to maintain relevance. 

This involves leveraging the latest technological advancements and innovative strategies.

The Insider's Guide to Crafting a Winning Financial Newsletter

Two significant trends set to redefine financial services newsletters are AI-driven personalization and blockchain technology.

AI-Driven personalization: Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly being utilized to personalize content according to subscriber preferences. 

AI-driven personalization goes beyond just using a subscriber's name. 

It can analyze reading habits and interaction patterns, tailoring the content to meet individual subscriber needs. 

This level of personalization can significantly boost engagement and open rates.

Blockchain technology: While most commonly associated with cryptocurrencies, blockchain technology's wider applications are increasingly being explored. 

In the context of newsletters, blockchain can potentially secure data and verify subscriber interactions, offering a new level of security and trust.


Alright, wrapping it up with a bang!

You've got the insights, the strategies, and the drive. Now, it's showtime. 

Ready to launch a financial newsletter that'll turn heads and spark conversations? 

Make your move with beehiiv. 

It's the ultimate platform to bring your financial newsletter dreams to life. 

Sign up with beehiiv today and join the ranks of successful financial newsletter creators who are already rocking it. 

Happy mailing!

Join the conversation

or to participate.