How to Nurture Your Newsletter Subscribers (ft. Head of Growth at beehiiv)

If you’ve ever felt like you’re shouting into the void every time you hit “send” on your newsletter, you’re not alone. Building an email list is one thing — keeping those subscribers engaged, loyal, and ready to act is a whole different game.

That’s where audience nurturing comes in. In a recent session at the Creator Summit, beehiiv’s Head of Growth, EJ White, shared his playbook for nurturing subscribers into superfans.

Whether you’re running a media empire, building a niche newsletter, or growing a content-driven business, these insights can transform your email list into a high-retention, high-conversion engine.

Table of Contents

• Top 6 Key Timestamps (From the Webinar)

• Top 6 Takeaways & Next Steps

• Key Resources & Tools Mentioned

• Closing Note and Final Thoughts

Top 6 Key Timestamps (From the Webinar)

Getting started 👇

00:00 - Introducing EJ

01:14 - What we'll be covering

Introduction to audience nurture strategies 🤝🏼

02:14 - What is audience nurturing and why is it important?

07:23 - The email growth flywheel

5 tactics to nurture your audience 📚

09:20 - Leverage segmentation

15:32 - Run a referral program

20:58 - Incorporate interactive elements

25:45 - Automate email journeys

29:32 - Use analytics & collect feedback

33:49 - Next steps

Q&A 🙋🏻‍♂️

34:43 - Examples of model newsletters

36:45 - Differentiation of newsletters and marketing emails

Top 6 Takeaways & Next Steps

1. Nurturing Builds Trust and Loyalty (Long Before the Sale)

Next Step: Map out your audience’s journey — from first subscribe to long-term engagement. Focus on consistently delivering value, not just promotion.

2. Personalization is Essential — Start with Segmentation

Next Step: Use your welcome survey, polls, and behavioral data to segment your list based on interests, engagement levels, and preferences.

3. Referral Programs Turn Subscribers into Brand Advocates

Next Step: Launch a referral program with tiered rewards (swag, exclusive content, shoutouts) that align with your audience’s values.

4. Make Your Emails Interactive (Because Readers Love to Click)

Next Step: Add a poll, quiz, or feedback prompt to every newsletter to boost clicks and signal engagement to inbox providers.

5. Automate the Welcome Experience for New Subscribers

Next Step: Build a 3-5 email welcome series that introduces your brand, highlights top content, and teaches subscribers how to get the most value from your emails.

6. Track Key Metrics & Continuously Ask for Feedback

Next Step: Set up regular performance reviews (weekly or monthly) to check open rates, click rates, and feedback — then adjust accordingly.

Key Resources & Tools Mentioned

• beehiiv Newsletter Platform

• HubSpot (Referenced for nurturing best practices)

• Matt McGarry Growth Resources (Referral Program expert)

• Morning Brew (Example of sophisticated automation)

• The Hustle (Case study in nurturing into monetization)

• Big Desk Energy (Example newsletter with stellar referral program)

Closing Note and Final Thoughts

Audience nurturing isn’t a trendy growth hack — it’s a proven strategy used by the best newsletters and email-first businesses in the game.

Whether you’re building your list from scratch or scaling to tens of thousands of subscribers, the core principles are the same: deliver consistent value, personalize your content, make engagement easy (and fun), and treat every email as a chance to strengthen the relationship.

As EJ put it, nurturing isn’t just about selling — it’s about showing up, building trust, and earning the right to make the offer when the time is right. If you follow these tactics, you’ll build a newsletter that doesn’t just grow — it thrives.